Skip to main content
Comment & Opinion

Failing to pay an Adjudicator’s fees leads to hefty costs sanctions

Our Construction and Engineering team has successfully represented an adjudicator in a claim for his fees: McLean & Anor v Winchester Medical Aesthetics Ltd [2026] EWHC 2941 (TCC).  The Technology & Construction Court granted summary judgment in favour of the adjudicator for 100% of the sums claimed, which included fees incurred during the adjudication, the further fees incurred pursuing payment, interest, and the entirety of the legal costs claimed.

The decision provides a useful reminder for both adjudicators and parties to adjudication of the importance of carefully considering an adjudicator’s terms of appointment, and the very limited circumstances in which an adjudicator’s fees can be challenged.

Factual Background

The underlying dispute arose from construction works carried out by Archiproject Limited (“Archiproject“) at premises owned by Winchester Medical Aesthetics Limited (“WMAL“). Following termination of the construction contract in November 2024, a dispute arose concerning alleged defects in the works and the sums due between the parties. In January 2025, WMAL commenced an adjudication seeking repayment of monies from Archiproject (the “Adjudication“).

The Royal Institute of British Architects (“RIBA“) nominated Mr Gerard McLean as adjudicator. On accepting the nomination, the adjudicator provided his terms and conditions to both parties, which WMAL and Archiproject signed and returned without objection.

Those terms expressed that remuneration would be calculated at an hourly rate of £324 plus VAT and disbursements, and provided that:

  • the adjudicator would be paid for all time spent on or in connection with the Adjudication, including where his decision was not subsequently enforced by the Court;
  • the parties would be jointly and severally liable for his fees and expenses;
  • unpaid invoices would attract interest at 8% above the Bank of England base rate; and
  • the adjudicator could recover the full amount of his administrative, legal and other costs incurred in recovering unpaid invoices.

The adjudicator issued his decision on 7 March 2025. His fees were not paid. The adjudicator contacted the parties on multiple occasions chasing payment, to no avail. Given the parties’ continued refusal to make payment, the adjudicator commenced Court proceedings to recover his fees.

Judgment

WMAL defended the claim on a number of grounds, including that the adjudicator had:

  • acted outside his jurisdiction and was in breach of natural justice;
  • failed to act impartially during the Adjudication;
  • refused to attend site during the Adjudication despite the alleged “seriousness and complexity” of the defects and despite allegedly “acknowledging that photographs alone were insufficient”; and
  • charged unreasonable or inflated fees.

WMAL also challenged the enforceability of the adjudicator’s terms as not being incorporated and in any event being unreasonable, and argued that a temporary discount offered in respect of the fees amounted to an unenforceable penalty.

The Court rejected those arguments and granted Summary Judgment, awarding the adjudicator the full amount of his fees incurred during and after the Adjudication (totalling £20,878.56), legal costs of £37,664.30, and interest at 8% above the base rate.

Enforceable Terms

HHJ Kelly rejected WMAL’s argument that the terms were onerous, unusual or had not fairly been brought to its attention. The fact that WMAL was a small company without specialist construction or adjudication knowledge did not alter the position. The terms had been clearly provided when the adjudicator agreed to act, the wording was not complicated and WMAL had signed the terms without objection. If clarification was required, WMAL could have sought legal advice. If WMAL did not wish to accept the proposed terms, it had been open to it to refuse the appointment, withdraw its notice of adjudication and recommence the adjudicator nomination process. The adjudicator’s terms were therefore enforceable in the circumstances.

The Court also confirmed that an adjudicator’s chargeable time can extend beyond determining an adjudication, including time spent at court and the costs of securing payment of fees, expenses and disbursements, where provided for by the terms of an adjudicator’s appointment.

Challenges to the Decision

The Court distinguished between the enforceability of the adjudicator’s decision and his separate contractual entitlement to be paid his fees. Even if WMAL had established that the Adjudicator acted outside his jurisdiction or in breach of natural justice, that might have been relevant to enforcement of the Adjudication decision against Archiproject, but it did not provide a defence to the adjudicator’s contractual claim for payment. His terms expressly provided that he was entitled to be paid irrespective of whether his decision was subsequently enforced.

In any event, the Court reiterated that the threshold for establishing a breach of natural justice in adjudication is high, reflecting the “speedy and rough and ready nature of the process“.

The Court similarly rejected WMAL’s criticism of the adjudicator’s decision not to undertake a site visit. Referring to Wycombe Demolition Ltd v Topevent Ltd [2015] EWHC 2692 (TCC), the Court confirmed the broad discretion afforded to adjudicators in determining the procedure necessary to decide a dispute.

Positive Case

The Court also considered WMAL’s assertion that the fees were unreasonable and inflated. Referring to The Vinden Partnership Ltd v ORCA LGS Solutions Ltd & Stourport on Severn Care Ltd [2017] EWHC B24 (TCC) and Fenice Investments Inc v Jerram Falkus Construction Ltd [2011] EWHC 1678, the Court confirmed that there is an implied assumption that an adjudicator’s fees will be reasonable in all the circumstances.

Simply putting an adjudicator to proof of the reasonableness of their fees is insufficient. A party seeking to challenge the fees must advance a positive case explaining in detail why the hours worked or fees charged were unreasonable.

Here, adjudicator’s time was supported by contemporaneous timesheets. WMAL produced no evidence that the hourly rate was out of line with comparable adjudicators, that the work could reasonably have been completed more quickly, identifying what amount of time would have been reasonable or any other positive case relating to the reasonableness of the fees.

Takeaway points

The judgment provides practical guidance for both adjudicators and parties engaging in adjudication.

For adjudicators:

  • Set out clear terms of appointment from the outset – an adjudicator’s terms should identify the applicable hourly rate, what constitutes chargeable time, responsibility for payment, interest and the costs recoverable if fees remain unpaid. Where appropriate, they should also make clear that entitlement to payment is not dependent upon subsequent enforcement of the adjudication decision.
  • Keep contemporaneous and sufficiently detailed time records – the Adjudicator’s timesheets provided important evidence supporting the reasonableness of the time spent and fees claimed.
  • Do not overlook post-decision costs – properly drafted terms can extend to time and costs reasonably incurred in pursuing unpaid fees, including court attendance, legal costs, expenses and disbursements, and can provide for the parties’ joint and several liability.
  • Adjudicators retain broad procedural discretion – the Court’s treatment of the proposed site visit is a reminder that decisions about the procedure required to determine a dispute are principally matters for the adjudicator and the adjudicator alone.

For parties in adjudication:

  • Review the adjudicator’s terms before accepting them – parties should not treat an adjudicator’s terms as a formality. Once accepted, the Court may hold the parties to them regardless of whether a party is “a small company with no specialist construction knowledge or knowledge of adjudication”.
  • Do not conflate a challenge to the decision with liability for fees – A jurisdictional or natural justice challenge which may affect enforcement of an adjudication decision does not necessarily provide a defence to the adjudicator’s separate contractual entitlement to payment.
  • A challenge to the amount of the fees requires proper evidence – simply asserting that an adjudicator’s fees are excessive or putting the adjudicator to proof is unlikely to be sufficient. A party should advance a positive case.
  • Consider the wider cost consequences before withholding payment – as this case demonstrates, a dispute over adjudicator’s fees can ultimately result in liability extending beyond the original fees to interest, the adjudicator’s further fees and substantial legal costs.

How can we support you

If you have any questions arising from this decision, or require advice on adjudication, the recovery or challenge of adjudicators’ fees, or the enforcement of adjudication decisions, please contact Carly Thorpe or Ibrahim Alyas.

If you’d like to receive this and other similar updates directly to your inbox, please click the link here.

Explore our Adjudication Basics video series here.

Carly
Thorpe

Partner

Construction & Engineering

CONTACT DETAILS
Carly's contact details

Email me

CLOSE DETAILS

Ibrahim
Alyas

Senior Associate

Construction & Engineering

CONTACT DETAILS
Ibrahim's contact details

+44 (0)113 283 2592

Email me

CLOSE DETAILS