Skip to main content
Comment & Opinion

Adjudication Matters: November 2026

Welcome to the November 2026 edition of Adjudication Matters, where we discuss the key developments in adjudication this month.

In this month’s bulletin we look at:

  1. When will a dispute over contract formation prevent enforcement of an adjudicator’s decision?
  2. When will financial difficulties justify a stay of enforcement of an adjudicator’s decision?

1. When will a dispute over contract formation prevent enforcement of an adjudicator’s decision?

Serapid Limited v Octavius Infrastructure Limited [2026] EWHC 2695 (TCC) [Link]

Factual Background

Octavius Infrastructure Limited (“Octavius“) was Network Rail Infrastructure Limited (“NRIL“)’s main contractor for an “Access for All” scheme at Chalkwell railway station in Essex. The works involved replacing a footbridge and installing two lifts (the “Project“). Octavius was negotiating the terms of the NEC3 Engineering and Construction Subcontract with Serapid Limited (“Serapid“) for the supply and installation of the lifts. Serapid began manufacturing the lift equipment for the Project while negotiations were still ongoing and no formal subcontract was yet signed.

NRIL later decided to use alternative lift technology. Octavius told Serapid that its lifts were no longer required, and a dispute arose.

The Adjudication

Serapid referred the dispute to adjudication, alleging wrongful termination and claiming £667,526. The adjudicator found that a contract existed and that Octavius had wrongfully terminated it. The adjudicator awarded Serapid £416,499.

Judgment

Octavius did not pay Serapid. Serapid applied to the court for summary judgment to enforce the adjudicator’s decision.

In the adjudication Serapid had argued that the subcontract was on the NEC3 terms and had been agreed around 6 June. The adjudicator agreed with Serapid on this basis. In the court enforcement proceedings Serapid also advanced an alternative argument that the subcontract had been concluded on a different date from that identified by the adjudicator or, alternatively, that a simple oral contract existed. These alternative arguments were rejected by the court as they had not been raised by Serapid in the adjudication itself.

Although the court generally adopts a robust approach to enforcing adjudicators’ decisions, here the court declined to grant summary judgment because it concluded that Octavius had a real prospect of establishing that no binding contract had been formed between the parties.

The evidence suggested that key legal and commercial terms remained under negotiation, and that the parties did not intend to be bound until a formal written subcontract was signed. Key factors that the court took into account were:

  • Serapid was unable to pinpoint a time when the relevant offer was made or acceptance received;
  • Serapid sought to reopen the price after June;
  • emails from the parties in June and July suggested that a signed contract would be required; and
  • Serapid started procuring the lifts on 3 June, which was before the date that Serapid said the contract had been entered into.

Applying the case of High Tech Construction Limited v WLP Trading and Marketing [2026] EWHC 152 (TCC) [1], the court confirmed that summary enforcement should be refused where the defendant has a real prospect of establishing that the contract on which the adjudicator’s jurisdiction depends was never formed.

Takeaway Points

This case serves as a reminder for parties to identify the contractual basis of their claim when referring a dispute to adjudication. Uncertainty as to whether a contract has been entered into may prevent an adjudicator’s decision from being enforced.

This case also highlights the risks for subcontractors and suppliers who start work before contract negotiations have concluded. Even under time pressure, parties should finalise their contractual arrangements before significant work is undertaken and expenditure is incurred to avoid uncertainty over their rights and significant legal and commercial risk. If works must start before the full subcontract is executed, parties should consider entering into a carefully drafted letter of intent.

2. When will financial difficulties justify a stay of enforcement of an adjudicator’s decision?

Avanton Capital CC Ltd v LUC Construction Ltd [2026] EWHC 2630 (TCC) [Construction Avanton Capital CC Ltd v LUC Construction Ltd [2026] EWHC 2630 (TCC) ]

Factual Background

Avanton Capital CC Limited (“Avanton”) engaged LUC Construction Limited (“LUC”) under a design and build contract on or about 15 November 2023 to construct three industrial units at Culvert Court, London. Practical completion was certified in April 2025, following which disputes arose concerning the value of the final account. On 22 May 2026, LUC commenced 7 separate adjudications before 7 different adjudicators, relating to different aspects of the valuation dispute. On 13 June 2026 Avanton commenced its own adjudication on the basis that LUC had failed to serve a valid payment notice or pay less notice in respect of a notified sum of £1,877,640.25. Avanton argued that LUC was therefore required to pay the notified sum in full.

Between June and July 2026, LUC obtained three adjudication decisions which found that contra-charges applied by Avanton in the final account had been overstated by an aggregate amount of £710,264.

However, on 9 July 2026, the adjudicator in the adjudication commenced by Avanton decided that LUC was required to pay Avanton £1,877,640.25 plus interest, together with £11,460 plus VAT in respect of the adjudicator’s fees and expenses.

Following that decision, the adjudicators dealing with the remaining adjudications resigned.

LUC did not make payment and Avanton applied to the court for summary judgment to enforce the adjudicator’s decision. LUC initially resisted enforcement on the basis of alleged breaches of natural justice, but abandoned those arguments before the hearing.

The issue remaining before the court was LUC’s application for a stay of execution. This would allow judgment to be entered in Avanton’s favour but temporarily prevent Avanton from enforcing it and recovering the money.

LUC relied on three principal grounds for the stay:

  1. That Avanton would probably be unable to repay the judgment sum if the adjudicator’s decision was subsequently reversed at the final determination of the dispute;
  2. That Avanton’s financial position had substantially deteriorated since the parties entered into the contract; and
  3. That enforcing the decision would be manifestly unjust because LUC would likely be forced to cease trading and would be unable to pursue the arbitration it had commenced against Avanton.

LUC also relied on the adjudication decisions finding that Avanton’s contra-charges had been overstated and maintained that it was likely to be a net payee following the final determination of the account.

Application for a Stay

The court considered the principles relating to a stay established in Wimbledon Construction Company 2000 Limited v Vago [2005] EWHC 1086 (TCC) which require the court to balance the policy that adjudication decisions should be enforced promptly, the successful party’s right not to be kept out of its money and the risk that the losing party may be unable to recover the money if the adjudicator’s decision is later reversed.

A stay may be appropriate where the successful party would probably be unable to repay the judgment sum following a final determination. It isn’t enough to establish that the successful party may be unable to repay. The applicant bears the burden of proving that repayment will probably not be possible.

Even where probable inability to repay is established, a stay will not usually be granted if the successful party’s financial position is the same as, or similar to, its position when the relevant contract was entered into. A stay will also not usually be granted where the successful party’s financial position has been caused, wholly or significantly, by the losing party’s failure to pay the amount awarded by the adjudicator.

The court also considered whether LUC could rely on its own inability to pay. Although a defendant’s own impecuniosity will rarely justify a stay, it may exceptionally be relevant where enforcement would create a ‘risk of manifest injustice’, including by depriving a party of any realistic opportunity to obtain a final determination which might reverse the adjudicator’s decision.

Where a party argues that enforcement would prevent it from pursuing a final determination, a bare assertion that it cannot pay will not be sufficient. The party must provide evidence that no realistic source of funding is available, including from its owners, associated persons or, where appropriate, external funders.

Judgment

The court refused LUC’s application for a stay and granted summary judgment in favour of Avanton.

Although Avanton had a negligible cash position, substantial secured borrowing and negative historical net assets, which supported a conclusion that Avanton might be unable to repay, critically, these factors did not establish the required probable inability to repay. The evidence showed that substantial group funding had historically been made available to Avanton and that its ultimate parent had significant positive net assets.

The court also found that, although Avanton’s accounting position had deteriorated numerically, LUC had knowingly contracted with an SPV with limited assets. LUC had therefore not shown that Avanton presented a materially different repayment risk from that inherent in the structure that LUC had accepted when entering into the contract.

LUC’s argument based on its own financial position also failed. LUC had not provided evidence addressing whether funds could be raised from other sources, including its shareholders. The court found this omission was “fatal” to LUC’s application and that LUC had fallen far short of establishing an inability to pay or that pursuing the arbitration would be stifled.

The court therefore entered summary judgment in Avanton’s favour.

Takeaway Points

This judgment highlights that:

  • The court’s starting position remains that adjudicators’ decisions should be enforced promptly. A stay of enforcement will only be granted in exceptional circumstances.
  • A party seeking a stay based on the successful party’s financial position must demonstrate a probable inability to repay the judgment sum. Evidence of a possible or material risk of non-payment isn’t enough.
  • Where a party knowingly contracts with an SPV with limited assets, the repayment risk inherent in that structure may be regarded as a commercial risk accepted at the time of contracting. A numerical deterioration in the SPV’s accounts will not necessarily establish a materially different repayment risk.
  • A losing party’s own inability to pay may exceptionally support a stay where enforcement would create a risk of manifest injustice, including by depriving that party of any realistic opportunity to pursue a final determination reversing the adjudicator’s decision.
  • A bare assertion that the losing party can’t pay won’t be sufficient. Evidence should address whether funding could be obtained from shareholders, owners, associated persons or external funders. LUC’s failure to address possible shareholder funding was fatal to its application.
  • Where competing financial risks are finely balanced, the court should favour the ordinary course and enforce the adjudicator’s decision.

How can we support you

If you have any queries in respect of this bulletin or would like to know more about adjudication please contact Carly Thorpe, Jessica Gates or Joshua Clough.

If you’d like to receive this and other similar updates directly to your inbox, please click the link here.

Explore our Adjudication Basics video series here.

 

 

References

[1] High Tech Construction Limited v WLP Trading and Marketing [2026] EWHC 152 (TCC);

[2] Wimbledon Construction Company 2000 Limited v Vago [2005] EWHC 1086 (TCC);

[3] CPR Part 24; and

[4] CPR 83.7.

Carly
Thorpe

Partner

Construction & Engineering

CONTACT DETAILS
Carly's contact details

Email me

CLOSE DETAILS

Jessica
Gates

Senior Associate

Construction & Engineering

CONTACT DETAILS
Jessica's contact details

Email me

CLOSE DETAILS

Josh
Clough

Associate

Construction & Engineering

CONTACT DETAILS
Josh's contact details

Email me

CLOSE DETAILS