Consultation on employment status reform: have your say and look ahead
17th November 2026
The long-awaited government consultation on employment status reform and protections for the self-employed opened in October 2026 and is still seeking views on proposals for future reform.
In this article, we look at the key proposals, what they could mean in practice and the steps organisations should consider taking now to prepare for possible change.
Employment status relates to the classification of the working relationship between an individual and the organisation engaging them and, importantly, determines which statutory employment rights the individual is entitled to. Broadly, there are three main categories for employment rights purposes:
Employees, who benefit from the widest range of employment rights (including unfair dismissal) but also have the most responsibilities and obligations towards their employer
Limb (b) workers, who have fewer rights and obligations than employees (their rights include holiday pay, national minimum wage and, where certain criteria are met, pension contributions)
Self-employed individuals, who have the least protection
Successive governments have considered reforming the existing employment status framework, but this would be a major undertaking given its inherent complexity and reform has not happened. Labour had pledged to move towards a single status of worker, with the aim of replacing the current three-tier system with a simpler two-part framework comprising workers and the genuinely self-employed (thus removing the distinction between employees and ‘limb b workers’). The new consultation does not go that far, although a move to single worker status has not been abandoned and is said to be a ‘long term goal’. For now, the existing framework of employee, limb (b) worker and self-employed status will remain. Instead, the government is consulting on three main proposals for reform:
Placing less emphasis on personal service in establishing worker status
Introducing a presumption of worker status so that the burden of proof is on the engager to demonstrate that an individual is not a worker
Strengthening protection for the self-employed, including a new right to a written statement for the self-employed
Whilst the proposals clearly have the gig economy in sight, the impact extends to other sectors that rely heavily on treating individuals as self-employed, including construction, hospitality, care and sport. They could bring many more individuals within the scope of limb (b) worker status. That in turn will give rise to complex practical issues around application of rights such as holiday pay and national minimum wage to individuals with highly flexible working arrangements.
It is important to remember that the consultation only concerns employment status for employment rights purposes, rather than the separate tax status framework under which individuals are classified as either employed or self-employed. However, reform could amplify the disconnect between the two regimes.
Given the implications of any future reform, organisations may want to familiarise themselves with the options being explored and consider whether to respond to the consultation. There are also practical steps that can be taken now to prepare for possible change, particularly for organisations that engage large numbers of self-employed individuals.
We have summarised the key proposals below.
Placing less emphasis on personal service
Under the current law, a key consideration when determining worker status is whether there is an obligation to provide personal service. If there is a genuine right to substitute (and this is utilised in practice with limited fetters), then this will typically prevent a finding of ‘limb b’ worker status. We have seen the emphasis that is placed on personal service in recent case law, including the recent Supreme Court ruling in IWGB v Central Arbitration Committee [2023] UKSC 43 (i.e. the ‘Deliveroo’ case). This found that the existence of a virtually unfettered right to substitute was inconsistent with an obligation of personal service.
However, the consultation raises concern about the rise in the use of substitution clauses, which are a key feature of self-employment, including that such clauses can be used to classify people as self-employed and prevent the requirement for personal service from being met even where substantial control is being exercised over how work is being carried out. The government is therefore seeking views on the role that personal service and substitution clauses should play in determining employment status, including whether the existence of a right of substitution should carry less weight where other factors point to worker status.
A number of options are being explored:
One option under consideration is to elevate the importance of control in the test for limb(b) worker status, so that in ‘step 2’ of the test both personal service and control are considered, rather than the focus being primarily on personal service
The consultation also identifies an individual’s ability to set the rate of pay or negotiate pay as a key factor in differentiating between limb (b) workers and the self-employed and that further consideration should be given to this as part of the limb (b) worker test. Views are sought on this
The government is also considering whether the threshold for what the courts consider to be personal service should be lowered. For example, by stating that any right of substitution limited only by the need to show that the substitute was as qualified as the contractor to do the work would be consistent with personal service
The government also seeks views on an alternative approach, namely, to legislate so that the existence of a right of substitution does not outweigh all other factors that point to worker status. This could be done, for example, by clarifying that the right on the part of a person to substitute their labour shall not be the sole or overriding factor in preventing someone from meeting the limb (b) worker test
Finally, the consultation asks whether the term ‘limb (b) worker’ should be replaced with something clearer and more readily understood
Improving compliance with the status framework
The government are exploring ways of strengthening compliance:
In particular, the government is considering a presumption of worker status by reversing the burden of proof for rights which flow from limb (b) status such as holiday pay and access to a workplace pension. Such a reversal already exists under national minimum wage legislation. This presumption would only apply to the question of whether the individual was entitled to the rights concerned
The government also proposes amending the Employment Tribunals Act 1996 so that repeated failures to recognise employment status can be treated as an aggravating factor in any breach of employment rights, resulting in an additional penalty for an employer
On state enforcement, the consultation seeks views on how the Fair Work Agency’s civil proceedings and legal assistance powers could best be used to determine employment status
The government is considering supplementing its guidance on employment status with an interactive online assessment tool, giving users a non-binding indication of employment status
Strengthening protections for the self employed
 A number of measures are proposed to extend protections for the self-employed, including:
The government is exploring extending the meaning of ‘worker’ for the purposes of specific employment rights and protections it is proposing to introduce. This would be similar to the approach currently found within the whistleblowing framework
The government is also seeking views on introducing a new right to a written statement for certain self-employed individuals, setting out key details about each contract for services that they enter into. It is considering having qualifying criteria for such a right, such as period of engagement or value of the contract
The consultation also proposes extending certain health and safety and blacklisting protections to the self-employed
Nothing has changed yet, and we don’t know exactly what reforms will be introduced or when. However, the direction of travel is clear, and the proposals should also be considered in the context of the expansion of right to work checks and the future introduction of measures in relation to zero and low hours working under the Employment Rights Act 2025.
There are some steps that organisations can take now to prepare for possible change, particularly those that engage large numbers of self-employed individuals, for example:
Identify areas of greatest exposure. Map populations of self-employed individuals, consider and plan for potential reclassification impacts
Review substitution arrangements. Consider the drafting of substitution clauses and the reality of substitution in practice (and any fetters on this right)
Look at control and pay. Consider the degree of control exerted over individuals, and their ability to set rates of pay, or negotiate pay. Consider the freedoms individuals have to decide how they carry out their day to day work (and how much control the organisation has over this), and their ability to turn down work
Consider the evidence. If the burden of proof is reversed, what evidence would the organisation have available to prove its case?
Focus on reality, not the labels. Remember that employment status is assessed by the reality of the working relationship, not simply by the labels the parties apply.
Our Clients
Resources
Services
Consultation on employment status reform: have your say and look ahead
17th November 2026
The long-awaited government consultation on employment status reform and protections for the self-employed opened in October 2026 and is still seeking views on proposals for future reform.
In this article, we look at the key proposals, what they could mean in practice and the steps organisations should consider taking now to prepare for possible change.
Employment status relates to the classification of the working relationship between an individual and the organisation engaging them and, importantly, determines which statutory employment rights the individual is entitled to. Broadly, there are three main categories for employment rights purposes:
Successive governments have considered reforming the existing employment status framework, but this would be a major undertaking given its inherent complexity and reform has not happened. Labour had pledged to move towards a single status of worker, with the aim of replacing the current three-tier system with a simpler two-part framework comprising workers and the genuinely self-employed (thus removing the distinction between employees and ‘limb b workers’). The new consultation does not go that far, although a move to single worker status has not been abandoned and is said to be a ‘long term goal’. For now, the existing framework of employee, limb (b) worker and self-employed status will remain. Instead, the government is consulting on three main proposals for reform:
Whilst the proposals clearly have the gig economy in sight, the impact extends to other sectors that rely heavily on treating individuals as self-employed, including construction, hospitality, care and sport. They could bring many more individuals within the scope of limb (b) worker status. That in turn will give rise to complex practical issues around application of rights such as holiday pay and national minimum wage to individuals with highly flexible working arrangements.
It is important to remember that the consultation only concerns employment status for employment rights purposes, rather than the separate tax status framework under which individuals are classified as either employed or self-employed. However, reform could amplify the disconnect between the two regimes.
Given the implications of any future reform, organisations may want to familiarise themselves with the options being explored and consider whether to respond to the consultation. There are also practical steps that can be taken now to prepare for possible change, particularly for organisations that engage large numbers of self-employed individuals.
We have summarised the key proposals below.
Placing less emphasis on personal service
Under the current law, a key consideration when determining worker status is whether there is an obligation to provide personal service. If there is a genuine right to substitute (and this is utilised in practice with limited fetters), then this will typically prevent a finding of ‘limb b’ worker status. We have seen the emphasis that is placed on personal service in recent case law, including the recent Supreme Court ruling in IWGB v Central Arbitration Committee [2023] UKSC 43 (i.e. the ‘Deliveroo’ case). This found that the existence of a virtually unfettered right to substitute was inconsistent with an obligation of personal service.
However, the consultation raises concern about the rise in the use of substitution clauses, which are a key feature of self-employment, including that such clauses can be used to classify people as self-employed and prevent the requirement for personal service from being met even where substantial control is being exercised over how work is being carried out. The government is therefore seeking views on the role that personal service and substitution clauses should play in determining employment status, including whether the existence of a right of substitution should carry less weight where other factors point to worker status.
A number of options are being explored:
Improving compliance with the status framework
The government are exploring ways of strengthening compliance:
Strengthening protections for the self employed
 A number of measures are proposed to extend protections for the self-employed, including:
What should organisations be doing now?
Organisations may want to consider responding to the consultation and contributing to the development of future policy in this area. The consultation closes on 8 January 2027 and is available here: Make Work Pay: employment status reform and protections for the self-employed  – GOV.UK.
Nothing has changed yet, and we don’t know exactly what reforms will be introduced or when. However, the direction of travel is clear, and the proposals should also be considered in the context of the expansion of right to work checks and the future introduction of measures in relation to zero and low hours working under the Employment Rights Act 2025.
There are some steps that organisations can take now to prepare for possible change, particularly those that engage large numbers of self-employed individuals, for example:
If you would like support in responding to the consultation or to discuss any of the issues raised in this article, please contact Andrew Rayment, Lucy Gordon, Charlotte Smith, Lorna Hopps, Shabana Muneer, Lauren Owens or any member of the employment team.
Manufacturing Horizon Scanner – November 2026
Logistics Horizon Scanner – November 2026
New consultation on whistleblowing reform and SFO whistleblower reward scheme
Preparing for change: Employment and Immigration law reforms affecting the sports industry
Preparing for change: Employment and Immigration law reforms affecting UK manufacturers
Andrew
Rayment
Partner
Head of Employment & Immigration
Andrew's contact details
andrew.rayment@walkermorris.co.uk
Lucy
Gordon
Partner
Employment & Immigration
Lucy's contact details
+44 (0)113 283 4552
lucy.gordon@walkermorris.co.uk
Charlotte
Smith
Partner
Employment & Sport
Charlotte's contact details
charlotte.smith@walkermorris.co.uk
Lorna
Hopps
Partner
Employment & Immigration
Lorna's contact details
lorna.hopps@walkermorris.co.uk
Shabana
Muneer
Partner
Employment & Immigration
Shabana's contact details
shabana.muneer@walkermorris.co.uk
Andrew
Rayment
Partner
Head of Employment & Immigration
Andrew's contact details
Email me
Lucy
Gordon
Partner
Employment & Immigration
Lucy's contact details
+44 (0)113 283 4552
Email me
Charlotte
Smith
Partner
Employment & Sport
Charlotte's contact details
Email me
Lorna
Hopps
Partner
Employment & Immigration
Lorna's contact details
Email me
Shabana
Muneer
Partner
Employment & Immigration
Shabana's contact details
Email me