Walker Morris / News & Insights / It’s Not a Fashion Statement, It’s a Dispute: what can your business learn about parody and trade marks from My Chemical Romance?
Walker Morris / News & Insights / It’s Not a Fashion Statement, It’s a Dispute: what can your business learn about parody and trade marks from My Chemical Romance?
Our Clients
Resources
Services
It’s Not a Fashion Statement, It’s a Dispute: what can your business learn about parody and trade marks from My Chemical Romance?
16th November 2026
“You can use parody in advertising and social media, but calling something a parody doesn’t automatically protect you from an IP infringement claim. Copyright law expressly allows for parody in certain circumstances, but there isn’t an equivalent general parody exception for trade marks. So, whether you’re planning to parody somebody else’s brand or someone is parodying yours, you need to look at what’s actually being used, which rights apply, and how the audience is likely to understand it.”
My Chemical Romance have found themselves in an unusual IP dispute after dancers performing at the band’s shows wore costumes said to resemble the Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders’ uniform.
It’s a useful reminder that calling something a parody doesn’t automatically put it beyond the reach of IP law.
In this article, we look at:
When imitation becomes part of the performance
The My Chemical Romance dispute isn’t simply about someone producing a similar cheerleading uniform. The costumes formed part of a performance of Teenagers, with dancers reportedly wearing outfits resembling the distinctive Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders uniform during a routine involving a staged confrontation and prop weapons.
The resemblance was part of the performance. The audience needed to recognise what was being referenced for the parody to work.
Your business could face the same issue in a less theatrical setting. Your marketing team might recreate a competitor’s advert for a joke, alter a famous logo for a social media post or reference another brand in a campaign. Equally, it could be your branding at the centre of someone else’s parody.
Does parody provide a defence?
UK copyright law expressly makes room for parody, allowing fair dealing with a copyright work for the purposes of caricature, parody or pastiche.
That doesn’t give you a free pass to copy someone else’s work because you’ve turned it into a joke.
The English courts considered this in Shazam Productions Ltd v Only Fools The Dining Experience Ltd. An interactive dining experience based on Only Fools and Horses couldn’t avoid copyright infringement by relying on parody or pastiche where it had essentially retold several of the show’s plots.
Suppose your business recreates a recognisable advert, changes the slogan and uses it to make a joke about a competitor. You need to ask what you’re parodying, what you need to copy to make the joke work, and whether your use is fair.
If you’re simply borrowing someone else’s creative work to make your advert more eye-catching, calling it a parody won’t necessarily help you.
Parody doesn’t give you a free pass on trade marks
There’s another issue which can easily be missed. The parody exception is part of copyright law. UK trade mark law doesn’t have an equivalent general exception allowing you to use a registered trade mark simply because you’re parodying it.
Even if you can rely on the copyright exception, you may therefore still have a trade mark problem.
If you’re using another business’s name, logo or other registered branding, you’ll need to consider its registrations and how you’re using them. Depending on the rights involved, issues such as confusion, misrepresentation, and detriment to the distinctive character or reputation of a mark may come into play.
Context matters too. An individual making a joke on social media isn’t necessarily in the same position as your business using a spoof of a competitor’s branding in a paid advertising campaign.
What if you want to parody a competitor?
There’s nothing inherently wrong with using humour in advertising, including humour directed at your competitors. But if the joke relies on their branding, look at what you’re actually proposing to use before it goes live.
Say you’re creating a LinkedIn post which recreates a competitor’s distinctive packaging, tweaks its logo and jokes that your product is better. You should consider:
You don’t necessarily need to strip out every recognisable reference. That could defeat the point of the parody. You do, however, need to understand which rights you’re dealing with and whether your joke takes more than it needs.
What if it’s your brand being parodied?
Someone might recreate your packaging in an advert, adapt your logo for social media or use a uniform closely associated with your business as part of a performance.
Before sending a cease and desist letter, work out exactly what they’ve used and which of your rights protect it.
If they’ve reproduced copyright material, consider whether the parody exception could apply. The use of your registered trade marks needs a separate analysis, while passing off or other legal issues may also be relevant depending on how your business is presented.
Remember that a parody usually needs its audience to recognise what’s being parodied. Someone seeing a spoof and immediately thinking of your business doesn’t necessarily mean they believe you created or endorsed it.
There’s also a commercial decision to make. Taking aggressive action against an obvious joke can sometimes give it far more attention than it would otherwise receive. Your legal options and the best response for your business won’t always be the same thing. We looked at similar considerations recently when discussing Fender’s approach to brand protection.
Famous Last Words?
The My Chemical Romance dispute makes for an eye-catching example, but you don’t need to be putting on a stadium show to run into the same problem.
If your business uses humour on LinkedIn, TikTok or Instagram, runs tongue-in-cheek advertising campaigns or pokes fun at competitors, you can learn from this dispute.
If you’re parodying somebody else, work out what you’re using and why you need it. Don’t assume that because copyright law expressly accommodates parody that trade mark law gives you the same freedom.
If your business is being parodied, take the same approach in reverse. Identify what’s been copied, which rights protect it and what you realistically want to achieve before responding.
Parody can be a powerful tool, but it doesn’t give you a free pass when it comes to IP rights. If you’re planning a parody or you’re concerned about someone else’s use of your brand, get in touch with our Intellectual Property team to discuss your options.
Walker Morris advises Unite Group on £60 million development site sale
Made in China, Protected in China: Preparing for China’s new Trade Mark Law
Technology & Digital round-up: August 2026
Lessons from Lasso: what happens when sport brands break the fourth wall
Striking a Chord: What all brand owners can learn from Fender’s latest IP battle
John-Joe
Massey
Senior Associate
Intellectual Property, Trade Marks & Designs
John-Joe's contact details
johnjoe.massey@walkermorris.co.uk
John-Joe
Massey
Senior Associate
Intellectual Property, Trade Marks & Designs
John-Joe's contact details
Email me
Meet the team